The definition
What is a hard call?
A hard call is a decision with real stakes that won't reverse cheaply, that analysis alone can't close, and that's yours alone to make.
Somewhere in your week there's a decision that keeps coming back. It was there Monday while you answered email. It followed you to the gym. It's the tab in your head that never closes, and every time it opens, the same arguments run in the same order, and nothing gets decided.
Everyone calls this indecision. It usually isn't. Indecision is a character flaw; this is a category error. You're treating a hard call like a normal decision, running it through the machinery you use for pricing tiers and feature debates, and the machinery keeps jamming because it was never built for this. Nobody taught you the difference because nobody teaches this in general. There's a thriving industry for every other part of a founder's job: growth, hiring, productivity, management, and even fundraising. But for the two or three decisions a year that actually determine whether any of that matters, the standing advice is "trust your gut," delivered by someone whose gut isn't attached to your consequences.
So let's define the difference, and what to do, properly.
A hard call is a decision with real stakes that won't reverse cheaply, that analysis alone can't close, and that's yours alone to make.
Most decisions aren't hard calls
A founder makes dozens of decisions each week (or each day). Treat them all as heavy and you end up moving too slowly to survive. Treat them all as light and risk critical mistakes that handicap your company.
Jeff Bezos put the underlying rule in his 2015 shareholder letter, and it's the best-known piece of decision doctrine in the valley for good reason. Some decisions are two-way doors: walk through, dislike what you find, walk back. Those should be made fast, at something like 51% confidence, by whoever's closest to them. Other decisions are one-way doors: consequential, hard to reverse, and deserving of slow deliberation.
A hard call has five marks:
- The stakes are real. Undoing it would cost a material amount of money, customers, contracts, pride, or another currency.
- Analysis alone won't close it. If one more spreadsheet or one more customer call would settle it, it's an operational decision wearing a costume.
- It's yours alone. You can't delegate it, and consensus can't make it. The room can advise but you're the one who needs to sign off.
- It cuts across currencies. The business case says one thing, and the money, the people, your health, or your identity complicate it.
- There's tension. It looks wrong from the outside, feels wrong from the inside, or both. If everyone around you instantly agrees, either it isn't hard or they aren't being honest.
If four or five of those ring true about a decision you're wrestling with then you have a legitimate hard call, and it deserves a different type of decision machine.
Don't let your decisions be tabs you never close. Either they're hard calls, and deserve a structured hour of your time to work through to make the call, or they're not and you can move forward even faster.
Get the Sunday issue.
One essay every Sunday on the decisions that define where your startup and your life actually go. Free.
No spam. Join 58,000+ founders.